WCAB Reduces Disability Rating but Allows Kite Addition in Blake
Decision: Blake v. State of Cal., No. ADJ11253479 (WCAB July 10, 2026).

A July 2026 WCAB panel decision illustrates how several technical rating doctrines can change a permanent-disability award.
Read the official WCAB panel decision.
A DMV Examiner’s Injury and a 72 Percent Award
Jeffrey Blake sustained industrial injury to his neck, psyche, head, and in the form of headaches. The WCJ found 72 percent permanent disability, no apportionment, a separate headache pain add-on, and addition rather than combination of orthopedic and psychiatric impairments.
In Blake, the State challenged the psychiatric rating, apportionment, the headache pain addition and the method of combining impairments. The Appeals Board changed two components and reduced the compensable rating to 47 percent. It retained the psychiatric rating and addition of impairments.
Section 4663 Apportionment Had to Be Applied
In Blake, the employer had an earlier award involving the neck and shoulder. But the earlier cervical rating used the Diagnosis Related Estimate method, while the current rating used the Range of Motion method. The Board found the latter appropriate for this recurrent spinal injury. The employer did not establish the specific amount of overlapping disability needed for a section 4664 deduction; the same body part did not establish that amount by itself.
That did not end the separate section 4663 inquiry into what caused the present permanent disability. Orthopedist Dr. Newton explained the earlier injury, continuing limitations and prior disc replacement, then compared those effects with the later injury and fusion. His deposition explained why he assigned 40 percent of cervical disability to earlier factors and 60 percent to the current injury. The Board in Blake found that reasoning substantial evidence. The 40 percent allocation concerned cervical disability, not an automatic 40 percent deduction from the entire award.
A Second Chapter 18 Pain Add-On Was Duplicative
The neurologist assigned a three-percent pain add-on for headaches even though the cervical rating already included a Chapter 18 pain increase. The Schedule permits a maximum three-percent pain addition from a single injury, and Blackledge requires underlying ratable impairment for an add-on.
The headache rating had no underlying headache whole-person impairment beyond that addition, and both additions appeared to arise from the same cervical mechanism. The Board in Blake excluded it on those grounds. It expressly declined to decide the exact contours of the Schedule’s single-injury pain limit.
Why Psychiatric and Orthopedic Impairments Were Added
First, the Board in Blake retained the psychiatric rating. Credited testimony described the car hitting dips at high speed, Blake’s head striking the roof twice, and the vehicle hitting a curb and becoming inoperable. That physical force supported the violent-act exception addressed in section 4660.1(c). The Board distinguished the lighter impact described in Duran from the force established by Blake’s credited testimony.
The Board in Blake also affirmed addition of the psychiatric and cervical impairments under the reasoning discussed in Kite and the en banc decision in Vigil. The psychiatric evaluator explained a synergistic cycle: Psychiatric symptoms worsened pain, and pain worsened psychiatric symptoms. That medical explanation supported adding the impairments instead of using the Combined Values Chart, the Schedule’s usual method for combining multiple ratings. It was the explained interaction, not the mere presence of two diagnoses, that supported departure here.
Practical Rating Lessons
The mixed result matters when reviewing an offer or award: A failed prior-award deduction does not eliminate a separately supported causal allocation. A valid psychiatric rating does not make a second pain addition valid. And a lower final rating does not mean the Board rejected addition of impairments. Identify which component changed and why before comparing the old and new totals.
The decision is fact-specific panel authority, but it offers a useful checklist for evaluating a permanent-disability report before trial.
Review Apportionment and Synergistic Impairment Ratings
Our firm can review permanent disability calculations, pain add-on disputes, and Kite addition arguments for injured workers in California. Bring medical evaluator reports, rating schedule calculations, and WCAB filings when you contact us. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.