Atlanta Falcons v. WCAB Limits California Claims by Out-of-State Pro Athletes

Athlete discussing an interstate work-injury record with a legal professional
The published decision applies Cal. Lab. Code § 3600.5’s specific exemptions for professional athletes.

In Atlanta Falcons v. WCAB, 114 Cal. App. 5th 1268 (2025), the California Court of Appeal applied two different measures of California work: A 365-day window for a particular employer and a separate career-wide test.

The court held that one early California contract does not automatically preserve a career-long cumulative-injury claim here.

Read the filed opinion and November 5 modification.

A 15-Year NFL Career

Wayne Gandy played 15 NFL seasons from 1994 through 2009. He began with the Los Angeles Rams under a contract signed in California, continued with the St. Louis Rams, and later played for Pittsburgh, New Orleans, and Atlanta. Six years after retiring, he filed a California cumulative-injury claim involving multiple body parts.

Limited Later California Work

During the final decade of his career, Gandy played eight California games. During the 365 days before his last California game for Atlanta, his duty days included four games and at least 250 practice days; only one game and no practices occurred in California. Atlanta supplied qualifying out-of-state workers’ compensation coverage.

The WCJ Found an Exemption

The WCJ found Atlanta exempt under Cal. Lab. Code § 3600.5, subdivisions (c) and (d). The WCAB rescinded, reasoning that Gandy’s original California contract supplied jurisdiction despite the athlete-specific exemptions.

Subdivision (c) Covered Atlanta

The Fourth District held that Atlanta satisfied subdivision (c). Gandy was temporarily in California because fewer than 20 percent of his relevant duty days occurred here, and qualifying coverage applied under another state’s law. The relevant window ended with his last California work for Atlanta, the November 30, 2008 game—not with his February 2009 retirement or the date he later filed the claim. The court counted the preceding 365 days for that employer. Atlanta Falcons, unmodified slip opinion, page 9.

Subdivision (d) Looks at the Career

When all final-year employers are exempt, California coverage remains only if the athlete satisfies both statutory conditions: at least two California-team seasons or 20 percent of career duty days in California or for California teams, and fewer than seven seasons with non-California teams. Gandy failed both. He had one California season, less than 20 percent qualifying duty days, and more than seven non-California seasons. The career percentage is different from the employer-specific percentage: The statute combines duty days for California-based teams with California duty days for other teams, then divides by all career duty days. It does not ask only how many games occurred in California. A California-based team is defined by where it plays a majority of its home games. Atlanta Falcons, unmodified slip opinion, pages 9–12; Labor Code section 3600.5(d)(1)(A), (g)(2)–(4).

One California Contract Was Not Enough

The court rejected the WCAB’s rule because it would make subdivision (d) largely superfluous. The Legislature adopted the later, more specific provisions to limit claims by out-of-state athletes while preserving access for athletes with defined, substantial California contacts. This was not a ruling that Gandy’s first contract was unsigned or invalid. The court accepted that he had been hired in California early in his career; that fact did not erase the later athlete-specific exemptions. Atlanta Falcons, unmodified slip opinion, pages 10–13.

Scope of Disposition and Costs

The court annulled the WCAB decision only as to Atlanta. It did not decide liability of the Steelers or Saints, limitations, contractual forum provisions, or due process. A later modification clarified that Atlanta’s writ costs were recoverable from Gandy, not the WCAB, without changing the judgment.

Practical Significance

These cases remain fact-specific. Athletes should preserve contracts, team assignments, game and practice schedules, travel records, and insurance policies. Keep the employer-specific window separate from the career totals: Identify the last California workday for the employer, reconstruct its preceding 365 days, and then build the separate team-by-team career history. Mark practice days as well as games, and show which team directed the work. The statute defines duty days by services under the employer’s direction and control pursuant to a player contract. Small differences in duty days, seasons, or final-year employment may change the result.

The California Supreme Court’s February 11, 2026 minutes denied the request to depublish the opinion in No. S294164. That entry is not a merits decision endorsing the reasoning, and it should not be described as a denied review petition. The opinion was certified for publication; the November 5 modification did not change the judgment.

Review Your Out-of-State Athlete Claim

Mishra X Trial Lawyers can review team contracts, game and practice schedules, and duty-day records to evaluate California workers’ compensation jurisdiction. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com to discuss your situation.