Amada Jimenez Herrera: Postinjury Raise and an Unresolved TTD Rate

Restaurant payroll ledger and wage records on a desk, representing evidence needed to calculate a temporary disability rate.

A raise after an injury can matter when disability starts later, but the higher hourly figure alone does not establish the weekly benefit. In Amada Jimenez Herrera v. Sweet T’s Restaurant + Bar, No. ADJ17939202 (Cal. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. Jan. 12, 2026), the WCAB upheld temporary-disability dates while leaving the weekly rate unresolved. The worker had continued working, received a raise and later stopped for surgery; the pay history did not identify the periods needed to finish the calculation. Jimenez Herrera, Opinion and Order, pages 1–3; adopted Report and Recommendation, pages 6–7.

The award separated entitlement from the unresolved weekly rate

The worker injured her right shoulder on June 7, 2022, then continued working for nearly a year. The October 8, 2025 Findings and Award found her temporarily totally disabled from April 12, 2023, through November 7, 2024. It awarded 22% permanent disability after apportionment and selected November 8, 2024, as the permanent-and-stationary date. But the amount of temporary disability indemnity remained for the parties to determine, with jurisdiction reserved if they disagreed. Illinois Midwest Insurance Agency, LLC, on behalf of ProCentury Insurance Company, sought reconsideration on the wage method, the permanent-and-stationary date, the impairment assessment, and statements in the worker’s trial brief. The Board adopted the WCJ’s report and denied reconsideration. Jimenez Herrera, Opinion and Order at 3; Report and Recommendation at 4–5.

The award answered whether and when temporary disability was payable. It did not establish a final average weekly wage or a specific weekly payment. The missing payroll detail still mattered even after the worker prevailed on entitlement.

Why the preinjury earnings year did not settle the calculation

The insurer argued for the average-weekly-earnings methods in Labor Code section 4453(c). Section 4653 sets temporary total disability payments at two-thirds of average weekly earnings during the disability period, with consideration of the worker’s ability to compete in an open labor market. Section 4453(c)(4) addresses the calculation method when the preceding methods cannot reasonably and fairly be applied: The measure is a sum reasonably representing average weekly earning capacity, with due consideration to actual earnings. Citing Rubalcava v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd., 220 Cal. App. 3d 901, 908 (1990), the adopted report treated the choice of method as a factual question. Jimenez Herrera, Report and Recommendation at 6.

Here, the worker testified that her hourly pay rose from $18 to $20 after injury and before she stopped working. The WCJ found that wages in the year before injury no longer reflected her true earning capacity during the later incapacity. The adopted report relied on Goytia v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd., 35 Cal. Comp. Cases 27, 30–32 (1970), for a dynamic conception of earning capacity and Grossmont Hospital v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. (Kyllonen), 59 Cal. App. 4th 1348 (1997), for using capacity when injury-date earnings would be unfair. It supported looking to the changed capacity rather than mechanically carrying forward older wages. The credible raise and the gap between injury and work stoppage drive this result; not every postinjury wage change automatically controls a temporary-disability rate. Jimenez Herrera, Report and Recommendation at 6–7.

The pay statement still needed a usable time period

Recognizing the higher hourly rate did not answer how many hours or what weekly wages to use. The WCJ found the pay-statement history the worker cited insufficient because the record did not show the exact periods covered by the payments. The parties were directed to develop the evidence further and encouraged to resolve the rate informally, with the WCJ retaining jurisdiction. Jimenez Herrera, Report and Recommendation at 7. An hourly rate alone is not a weekly earnings calculation; the relevant pay periods, hours, and other earnings must be identifiable before a supported figure can be derived.

For a similar dispute, the record should connect each pay statement to its start and end dates, hours paid, hourly rate, and any other compensation included in the asserted average. The date the worker stopped working and the dates of temporary disability should be clear. Those are practical evidentiary steps drawn from the gap in this record, not a new checklist imposed by the panel.

The medical findings remained a separate issue

The panel also upheld reliance on the qualified medical evaluator’s explained medical findings for the permanent-and-stationary date and impairment assessment. Those findings supported the broader award but did not establish the missing wage periods or settle the weekly rate. Jimenez Herrera, adopted Report and Recommendation, pages 5, 7–9.

What the panel decision offers to a wage-rate dispute

Jimenez Herrera illustrates two linked points: A material wage change before disability may make an injury-date earnings period unfair as a measure of lost earning capacity, and the replacement calculation still needs records that establish the relevant weekly earnings. The case turns on its own testimony and incomplete pay history. The WCAB panel’s reasoning is useful because it ties the wage calculation to the testimony and incomplete pay history in this record. A party should test the applicable section 4453 method against the actual employment and earnings record, rather than assume either the earliest or latest hourly figure decides the amount.

Questions about a raise before temporary disability

Does a raise after an injury necessarily increase temporary disability benefits?

No automatic increase follows from the raise alone. In this case, the raise made the preinjury earnings year an unfair proxy for the worker’s later earning capacity, but the exact average weekly wage remained unresolved because the pay-period record was incomplete. Jimenez Herrera, Report and Recommendation at 7.

Can the WCAB decide temporary-disability dates while reserving the rate?

Yes. The award identified the period of temporary total disability and left the weekly rate for the parties to determine on a better record, with jurisdiction reserved for a dispute. Jimenez Herrera, Report and Recommendation at 5, 7.

Assess the wage record before calculating the disability rate

Mishra X Trial Lawyers can assess a disputed wage calculation against the pay history, disability dates, and governing law. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.